So I had a dream last night (bear with me, because I know that studies have shown that nothing is more boring than listening to other people's dreams), I had a dream that we actually had to say in person everything we wrote online to the people we were saying it about/to.
It was intense. It was probably also prompted by
this post by
sparkindarkness, which features a video from Holy Bullies and Headless Monsters showcasing the homophobic tweets that people sent #tomyunbornchild.
In any case, I'd really like for all of you to take a moment and think about everything you've ever written about/to anyone on the internet. Now imagine them standing in front of you.
How many of you would still call them the names you've called them online? Some of you would, I know. Some of you aren't cowards, hiding behind screen names or sometimes not even that. Some of you would
own what you say, think, and feel, by saying it to a person's face.
But many of you wouldn't. Because to many of you, the people represented by every line of text one finds online (even the bots were programmed by someone), EVERYONE is a bot. No one is real. We're all just characters in a big game. Some of it is human socialization. When interacting with others I think it's 70% how you look, 20% how you say something, and 10% what you actually said (numbers pulled directly from my ass, but I think they're pretty close to reality).
Online, it's 100% what you said. Online, we are what we type. Not only that, but unlike with most face-to-face interaction, there is no body language, no nuance of expression, nothing but words on a screen. To many of you, that's all I am, for better or worse, I'm words on a screen.
I've said and done hurtful things, both in person and online. Online, it's forever. There is no way to "make up" with someone online, not really, because the connection is at once tenuous and permanent. If I misspeak offline, I still may make an enemy for life (or at least lose a chance at a friendship), but let's be honest here - human memory fades and it's much easier to make amends to a person than a screen name.
The internet doesn't fade. The internet is forever. Every poor choice of words, shitty opinion, sleepy tirade, or stupid comment is just
there. Even if someone deletes, there are screencaps and WayBack machines.
Where am I going with this? I'm not really sure, I just needed to articulate my unease with the idea that to many people with whom I interact online, I'm not a real person. Why else would so many people call the world outside the internet "real life," when in fact it is "offline life?" (
rm did a good post about this a while back that I'm too lazy to go and look up.)
I remember once reading a fiction story that described a mental disorder in which a person didn't believe that every person around them was in fact "real." They knew that they were "real," and felt that others could be "real" as well, but for them most people were simply two-dimensional characters, with no true thoughts, feelings, or lives of their own.
I am not a character in Sim City. Neither are you. What we say and do here may be escapism from everyday pressures such as bills, work, homophobia, racism, sexism, or just the general pain of living, but everyone with whom we interact has problems, maybe not just like ours, but problems all the same. Everyone has pain. Everyone has tragedy. Your pain does not make my pain less, nor does my pain make your pain less, nor should it. We are all human beings.
We all have privilege to one degree or another (simply the act of being able to get online to read this- Hell, simply the act of
reading is a privilege), but there is no one can see this who has not suffered. No one who has not felt pain or loss or alienation from others.
And the internet is the ultimate alienation. We're all just words on a screen to one another, which means that far more than with face-to-face or even telephone interactions, we must choose our words with care, thoughtfulness, and patience. We must not be rash, or hasty, or cruel if we can avoid it.
But we are. Unless you're a total lurker (as I was for many years - ah, the salad days!), the odds are good that you've said or done something online that has hurt someone else. That hurt has been real. It was a real person you were calling horrible and while you may have felt they deserved it (and they certainly may have), I still have to ask - Would you have said it to their face?" Or signed the name that people know you face-to-face to it?
Do you own what you say, think, and feel here where you don't have to? Would you say everything you think of me if we met offline?
I hope you would. I hope I would. Actually, I know I would because I have. I've told people that I just met that they had terrible opinions and I've called people out at work and school when they've said something nasty. Not every time, but then, I don't engage every time online, either. And just as with here, I don't win friends and influence people... but sometimes I do, :).
Again, where am I going with this? Nowhere, obviously. I'm just a 35-year-old, white, US-born woman, sitting in my pajamas in an office chair with a tabby cat on my desk in my messy office, listening to my bed call my name because I can go back and sleep a little longer today before I go to work, writing about a dream I had last night.
I have homework to do, bills to pay, and paperwork I need to file. I have problems. I have pain. I broke down crying for a moment last night when I saw the same tabby cat that's sitting on my desk right now out of the corner of my eye and for a moment, my brain forgot Buttons was dead. I have joy. I cuddled up with my husband last night and I'm done with school for the week. I also cooked myself chicken for breakfast.
I'm a boring, ordinary, living, breathing human being with an average number of problems that are almost certainly worse in my head than they are in reality.
I'm real, though. I'm a real person with real thoughts, real feelings, and real pain. You can hurt me, if you have that desire.
I am a living, breathing human being. Nothing more, but certainly nothing less.
And so are all of you. I'm going to try to do better about remembering that.
I would sign my full name to this, but that's against LJ's TOS, so I'll just say - Eh, perhaps not.
With warmest regards,
Beverly J. Horsley