You've All Had This Happen
Feb. 22nd, 2011 05:16 pmNot too long ago, someone commented in my journal with an icon that was a picture of Hitler with the caption, "My mommy chose life." I banned the icon (it was the first time I'd ever deleted a comment, which caused a bit of angst for me because I'm just like that) and eventually the person who used it when they came back to be shitty because I'd made a public post supposedly 'shaming' them when all I was doing was essentially making a post for future reference - "Hey everyone, no Hitler or Nazi imagery of any type allowed here."
That's not what you've all had happen, heh.
No, what happened was I later realized that the icon was not just offensive, it was also WRONG. Hitler's mommy didn't CHOOSE life. Hitler's mommy had no choice in the matter whatsoever. When Hitler was born in 1889, his mommy had basically no rights as a person. She couldn't vote, let alone go and get abortion, and was generally defined by her role as 'Hitler's mommy' or 'Hitler's daddy's wife'. She wasn't a person - she was a broodmare and broodmares don't get to choose whether or not they stay pregnant.
Using that icon as a dig at the Pro-Life crowd may get some surface attention, but it ignores the essential truth that Hilter's mommy was a woman and women don't get to make decisions about whether or not they have children. Oh, we say they do now, but as I pointed out yesterday, with 87% of the counties in the US not having access to abortion providers, we really don't mean it. At least not in the US or in other parts of the world where women are still chattel, which I believe comprises a greater percentage of the world's population than not.
I didn't get to tell the owner of that icon any of this because I didn't realize it until WAY after the fact and wow, does it suck thinking of the perfect comeback a month later (or however long it's been), but hey, at least I get to share it with all of you, :).
ETA: Hilter's mommy's name was Klara. Thanks,
darth_eldritch.
That's not what you've all had happen, heh.
No, what happened was I later realized that the icon was not just offensive, it was also WRONG. Hitler's mommy didn't CHOOSE life. Hitler's mommy had no choice in the matter whatsoever. When Hitler was born in 1889, his mommy had basically no rights as a person. She couldn't vote, let alone go and get abortion, and was generally defined by her role as 'Hitler's mommy' or 'Hitler's daddy's wife'. She wasn't a person - she was a broodmare and broodmares don't get to choose whether or not they stay pregnant.
Using that icon as a dig at the Pro-Life crowd may get some surface attention, but it ignores the essential truth that Hilter's mommy was a woman and women don't get to make decisions about whether or not they have children. Oh, we say they do now, but as I pointed out yesterday, with 87% of the counties in the US not having access to abortion providers, we really don't mean it. At least not in the US or in other parts of the world where women are still chattel, which I believe comprises a greater percentage of the world's population than not.
I didn't get to tell the owner of that icon any of this because I didn't realize it until WAY after the fact and wow, does it suck thinking of the perfect comeback a month later (or however long it's been), but hey, at least I get to share it with all of you, :).
ETA: Hilter's mommy's name was Klara. Thanks,
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)